Poll: Who should it be?

Ark Kuvis · 09-29-2009 02:41 AM

Ted...

Not only does this Horace guy come from a Gaiden Chapter, meaning you don't need to get him in order to complete the game, he's not a main character. Marth, Ike, and Roy were all the main characters of the games they appeared on.

Same goes for all Fire Emblem characters who aren't lords. Exception being main secondary characters, like Soren from PoR and Sheedna from Shadow Dragon, who'd appear as Assist Trophies.

**Tonberry2k** · 10-26-2009 04:48 AM

Bumping this to say I'll be locking it on Tuesday. Vote while you can!

Ark Kuvis · 10-26-2009 12:08 PM

(09-28-2009 11:05 PM)Ark Kuvis Wrote: Guys, I think it's pretty clear that no one on this forum knows about Fire Emblem. Show of hands who've actually played a game in the franchise.

Because 1) We still have Roy for a playable character. 2) We have Black Knight on the list of playable characters. and 3) the only non Tellius Saga character is Lyn, who isn't even the main character from the game she resides in.

Honestly, why are we adding another Fire Emblem character? There hasn't been an actual new game in the franchise since Radiant Dawn (Shadow Dragon was a remake). If there was, we could just add the lord from that.

Especially when we have better characters to add, such as Axe Wielding Psyenergy Adept Issac from Golden Sun, or how about the rebellious marksman Saki from Sin and Punishment? Heck, why is CAPTAIN FALCON the ONLY F-Zero character.

Fire Emblem doesn't deserve 4 characters if there isn't an obvious candidate for the position. If you really want someone new, replace Roy with Fire Emblem: Blazing Sword hero Eliwood. I would've pushed for him earlier, but he's basically a Roy clone. Heck, if you want, have Eliwood, Lyn, and Hector fight as one. Switching like Zelda and Pokemon Trainer. They'd be more deserving than Roy. There was a reason he was cut from Brawl, guys, and Ike wasn't just added to replace him.

D2S-Speed · 10-26-2009 01:50 PM

@ Ark Kuvis: What?
Okay first Roy was cut from Brawl because supposedly Nintendo thought that they wanted at least one English Fire Emblem character. Also that would be horrible if Roy switched with Lyn and Hector what kinda final smash would they have? The only reason there are three poke'mon for Poke'mon Trainer is because he can use triple finish with a combo of attacks, besides like you said Lyn wasn't really a Main character in the game she was in. So I really think we should leave this up to everyone else, not just a decision based on your own ideas.

Kairos · (10-26-2009)

4th FE character not really needed.

Sure, it'd be neat. But right now another fucking sword user and fucking Micaiah are in the lead.

Gold · 10-26-2009 04:50 PM

(10-26-2009 02:29 PM)Mr.Bland Wrote: 4th FE character not really needed.

**Tonberry2k** · 10-26-2009 04:52 PM

Should we redo this poll with a "no new FE character" option? we DID kind of get screwed with the crash...
But I feel like one of the points of making a new version of the game is to add more characters.

Kitsu · 10-26-2009 05:07 PM

I'd say yes, but ROY! NO!
But really, I have no problem with no 4th character, I just don't want Roy to be the 3rd...

Gold · 10-26-2009 05:15 PM

(10-26-2009 04:52 PM)Tonberry2k Wrote: Should we redo this poll with a "no new FE character" option? we DID kind of get screwed with the crash...
But I feel like one of the points of making a new version of the game is to add more characters.

Yes.

I agree that the one of the points of the new version is to add new characters, but I really feel there is no reason for it to be an FE character. It doesn't seem to me that anybody wants it and there were lots of other choices in the oter poll. I'm pretty sure Isaac was next in the line was he not?

Angelglory · (10-26-2009)

And while we're on the topic of 4th characters, do we really need a 4th Mother character too?

Kairos · 10-26-2009 05:22 PM

I'd like Mother, but seeing Porky go would be kinda nice to give a chance to someone else.

**Tonberry2k** · 10-26-2009 05:22 PM

I'm going to stick by the Mother characters. They're deeper and more unique than the Fire Emblem characters, not to mention more popular.

Gold · 10-26-2009 05:24 PM

(10-26-2009 05:18 PM)Angelglory Wrote: And while we're on the topic of 4th characters, do we really need a 4th Mother character too?

Cannot thank hard enough.
I don't feel we need MaskMan either.

Kairos · (10-27-2009)

tbqh 6 pokemon seem a little extreme.

Getting rid of Lucario or Pichu wouldn't be a bad idea.

Kitsu · (10-26-2009)

Doesn't that leave us with just first generations, though?

Really, this just takes us back to the previous arguments we had in the character roster thread.

Poll: Who should it be? This poll is closed.
Micaiah	13	21.31%
Sothe	7	11.48%
Black Knight	9	14.75%
Lyn	25	40.98%
Other	7	11.48%
Total	61 votes	100%

Threaded Mode \| Linear Mode Fire Emblem character suggestions
Author	Message