RE: The Smash Bros. Project 4.5
i started getting lazy
from top to bottom
C. Falcon: his right leg (our left) is too short and needs to be extended slightly, his right leg should go out further as well. upper body is fine
donkey kong: too many highlights on the upper body on the left side where the shading should be, there should also be more shading under the arm
samus his legs are in too awkward of a position, they shouldnt be in exactly the same position, shading is fine (other than the obvious block)
link's right leg is in an awkward position and the skirt is too tight. shoe on his right leg is also incorrectly shaded
yoshi has too many shades for the style, or they have too much contrast between them, or not enough (not sure), back of body should also be shaded because the tail is not the only spot that should be shaded. lightsource at too high of an angle, like 45 degrees rather than 25ish
luigis head, neck, upperbody and upper arms should all be thicker, shading is fine, but his right leg again is awkward
fox needs to be taller, pose and legs smoothed out and the shading on his legs is coming from an opposite lightsource than that of his head
mario is fine
ness' hands go out a bit too far, imo, but thats just preference.
pikachu's head is too big, and the shades need more contrast, as well as the lightsource fix.
jigglypuff's outline is too dark compared to the style, same with kirby, shapewise these 2 are fine, except jigglypuffs feet should be slightly bigger
bowser looks like a color reduction, and nothing else, completely obselete of the style.
ganondorf you cant even recognise his features
mewtwos pose is in an odd position, with the upper body pose the legs should be more spread out.
marths head is too small, and his legs too short but otherwise hes p good.
zelda is leaning too far forward
sheik's right leg is in an awkward position, and hes leaning too far back, and his hat is shaded incorrectly
peach is leaning a bit too far forward, move her upper body back a pixel
wheres roys cape??? legs dont make sense, nor does any of the shading (which also needs more contrast)
falcos legs are too straight, otherwise hes p good
young link has the same problem as old link
ice climbers need more contrast
2nd game and watch is better, and is fine
pichu needs more contrast and thats about it
charizard's shading doesnt make sense, and in some places its a bit pillowed and his outline is too dark, good lineart and pose though.
dedede is shaded too realistically, with shades that dont work and looks too round compared to the nice flatness of mario and other good sprites.
snake needs to be completely redone, hes facing the wrong way, his arms are in a good position, but his legs arent, they are in the kinda dont do pose you have on the front page
zss is waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too thin, but otherwise is decent, and needs finishing
r.o.b. is facing completely right but shouldnt be, he should be in style. also hes too big imo
pikmin are fine, but olimar should have his legs spread apart and be in a battle ready pose
ikes limbs are way too short and should be extended and his sword moved into a decent pose also a bit more contrast
trainer needs lighter outline, new legs that suit the arms and more contrast
pits upper body is fine but his lower body needs fixing, complete redoing
Lucarios shading and colours are decent though the anatomy and pose are completely off, he should be facing between forward and right not pure right
the third sonic is great, though could use some more shading on the spines
venusaur needs to face not right once again, and its shading is from the top not from the 25 degree angle
wario is great, but his head needs to move back a pixel or two
lucas' head turn is fine, because his body is facing the right angle, and looks good, and the shading is great too
diddy obviously needs redoing, size, pose. colours, anatomy, nearly everything is off. its a decent sprite but nothing like it should be
toon link has the wrong lightsource, and his left leg needs redoing (pose wise)
wolf is just crap, no offense whoever made it but it could use complete redoing
squirtle is fine, but his feet is weird, and below the mouth seems odd
metaknight is near perfect, no complaints from me
items: smash ball too big
most things are way too big or too simplistic. the crates are fine
so are the barrels
party baloon has wrong lightsource
hammer has wrong lightsource
targets are pretty bad